PSA Lost Your Cards. Who Is Legally Responsible?

The Card Wire

Oct 23

Someone Pulled a $45,000 1st Edition Flareon Out of a $1,000 Grail Break Pack

Sold for $25,800 USD on Fanatics Collect. One lucky collector turned a $1,000 pack into a $42k buyback offer

Oct 22

Kessler's Silver Rookie Made a Round Trip Before His Perfect Lakers Debut

Sold for $95 USD on eBay. Nobody has sold a PSA 10 of his 2022 Prizm Silver since he made all 12 of his shots for 26 points in Wednesday's 127-105 win over the Warriors.

AuctionOct 22

Luffy's Two Legends Treasure Rare Is Back to Its Spring Price

Bid at $422 USD on eBay. A PSA 10 closes on eBay tonight after one sold for $1,895 in June.

GameOct 21

Collectors Still Haven't Forgiven Drake Maye for the Super Bowl

Sold for $128 USD on eBay. Collectors have paid less for his PSA 10 Prizm rookie every month since the Patriots lost the Super Bowl, heading into Thursday night's game in Chicago.

SaleOct 21

Luka Promised LA a Title Run as His Prizm Rookie Stayed Flat All Year

Sold for $200 USD on Fanatics Collect. A PSA 10 of his 2018 Prizm rookie sold for $200 on the day of the Lakers' opener against the Warriors, against around $209 last October.

SaleOct 21

LeBron's Chrome Rookie Got Cheaper Right Before His Sixers Debut

Sold for $4,200 USD on eBay. Four PSA 9 copies of his 2003 Topps Chrome rookie sold for less than $3,850 at Fanatics Collect on Oct. 18, two days before he beat the Knicks at Madison Square Garden.

ReleaseOct 21

Hancock's Manga Rare Heads Into the New Heroines Set Below Its June Price

Sold for $2,580 USD on Alt. A PSA 10 of Boa Hancock's manga rare from 500 Years in the Future sold for $2,580 on Alt on Oct. 15, against $3,750 at its June high.

PromoOct 21

Naruto's Gen Con Chakra Card has recovered after October's pull back

Sold for $4,200 USD on eBay. Bandai is handing out the same card at Spiel Essen and Paris Games Week from Oct. 22 to 25, without the Gen Con mark collectors have been paying up for.

ReleaseOct 21

Lorcana's First Enchanted Mickey Has Held Above $1,000 Since June

Sold for $1,650 USD on eBay. Hyperia City, the Disney Lorcana set that adds Pixar's Coco, reaches stores Oct. 23 with a PSA 10 of the first set's Enchanted Mickey selling for $1,650 on Oct. 7 against around $430 a year ago.

Oct 20

Angel Reese's Silver Prizm Rookie Doubled on the Dream's Finals Run

Sold for $35 USD on eBay. She had 30 points and 16 rebounds on Monday as the Dream evened the Finals heading home to Atlanta for Game 3.

AuctionOct 20

Kimi Antonelli's $878,400 Rookie Auto Is F1's Second-Biggest Card Sale

Sold for $878,400 USD on Goldin. His base Topps Chrome rookie has been climbing all season as he heads to Austin with a chance to clinch the title.

MarketOct 19

Junior Caminero's PSA 10 Rookie Has Tripled While Raw Copies Still Sell for $2

Sold for $118 USD on eBay. With the Rays playing for the pennant, all the gains in Junior Caminero's rookie have gone to the graded copies.

MarketOct 19

Puka Nacua's Record Week Hasn't Moved His Rookie Card

Sold for $63 USD on eBay. Collectors have paid the same for Nacua's PSA 10 Prizm rookie for a year straight, catch record included.

MarketOct 19

LeBron's Rookie Card Cooled Off Before His First Sixers Game

Sold for $5,951 USD on eBay. Collectors paid up after he chose the Sixers in July, then started selling his 2003 Topps rookie well before Tuesday's debut at Madison Square Garden.

More wires

Upcoming Card Releases and Auctions

Featured Stories

Hobby

PSA Lost Your Cards. Who Is Legally Responsible?

After thieves stole nearly $1 million in graded cards from a FedEx truck, PSA promised to compensate affected collectors. But who is legally responsible when a grading company loses your cards, and what happens if you disagree about their value?

Card Market Movers

Full leaderboard

Rising, 30 days

+48.9%
Justin Verlander
2006 ToppsPSA 10 · $136 USD
+48.8%
Barry Bonds
1987 ToppsPSA 10 · $1,562 USD

Falling, 30 days

$Elian Rosario 2026 Bowman Chrome International Refractor Autograph Baseball, Raw$
−62.8%
Elian Rosario
2026 Bowman Chrome International Refractor AutographRaw · $14 USD
−53.6%
Owen Ayers
2026 Bowman Chrome Prospect AutographsRaw · $17 USD