Skip to content

Search CardWire

↑ ↓ to navigate · Enter to open · Esc to close

CardWire menu

Joe Burrow's rookie card lags the MVP odds on November's football Buy List

From a $12 Fernando Mendoza to a $1,436 Patrick Mahomes, these are the 10 football cards to buy in November.

By Jeff Newman
Josh Allen 2018 Prizm, Joe Burrow 2020 Prizm, and Patrick Mahomes 2017 Donruss Optic rookie cards in PSA 10 slabs
Photo: Fanatics Collect

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026.

Get The Card Wire

Essential card-market reporting, notable sales, and context delivered to your inbox.

We will email a confirmation link. Unsubscribe at any time.

The best football card to buy this month belongs to the MVP favorite. Joe Burrow became the odds-on MVP favorite in the last week, but his 2020 Prizm rookie in PSA 10 still sells for about $111, while the cards of the quarterbacks chasing him have already run.

I built this list like a draft board, starting with budget picks any collector can grab and working up to the high-end cards worth saving for.

What are the best football cards to buy right now?

My ten picks for November, with what each one is selling for this month:

  • Fernando Mendoza, 2026 Topps Rainbow Foil, raw: about $12
  • Joe Burrow, 2020 Prizm, PSA 10: about $111
  • Trevor Lawrence, 2021 Prizm, PSA 10: about $163
  • Barry Sanders, 1989 Score, PSA 9: about $194
  • Caleb Williams, 2024 Prizm, PSA 10: about $304
  • Jerry Rice, 1986 Topps, PSA 8: about $427
  • Jayden Daniels, 2024 Prizm Silver, PSA 10: about $608
  • Walter Payton, 1976 Topps, PSA 6: about $636
  • Josh Allen, 2018 Prizm, PSA 10: about $750
  • Patrick Mahomes, 2017 Donruss Optic, PSA 10: about $1,436

Why buy Joe Burrow's rookie card now?

Burrow has accounted for four or more touchdowns in five straight games, tying the NFL record. ESPN's odds made him the odds-on MVP favorite at -115 on Nov. 17, up from +210 a week earlier. The chart shows the Prizm PSA 10s of Burrow, Brock Purdy, and Josh Allen since August. Purdy's and Allen's ran with their teams' records while Burrow's barely moved. I'd buy Burrow's card before it catches up to the odds, because of the three it's the one with the most room to move if he wins.

​

Which football cards under $200 are worth buying?

1. Fernando Mendoza, 2026 Topps Rainbow Foil, raw

​

Raw copies sell for about $12. The Raiders traded Kirk Cousins to Minnesota at the Nov. 10 deadline and handed Mendoza the job. He ran for a touchdown on his first drive as a starter against Seattle on Nov. 15. ESPN's odds now make him the Offensive Rookie of the Year favorite at +230. I'd buy a few at this price before his game at Denver.

2. Joe Burrow, 2020 Prizm, PSA 10

​

A PSA 10 sells for about $111, close to what it sold for in late summer, before he went on his touchdown run. With 7,821 copies graded a 10 at PSA, there's always one listed. I'd buy at $111 instead of waiting for him to win the award.

3. Trevor Lawrence, 2021 Prizm, PSA 10

​

A PSA 10 sells for about $163. Lawrence has the Jaguars at 7-2 and sits at +500 for MVP. His is the hardest card to gem in the MVP race, with 421 of the 4,721 copies PSA has graded getting a 10. I'd buy the 10 under $170.

4. Barry Sanders, 1989 Score, PSA 9

​

A PSA 9 sells for about $194. Its 53 sales in the last 30 days are the most of any card on this list. I'd buy the 9 under $200 because you'll never wait long for a buyer when it's time to sell.

Which football cards are worth buying for $300 to $700?

5. Caleb Williams, 2024 Prizm, PSA 10

​

A PSA 10 sells for about $304. Williams has the Bears at 7-2 going into their Thanksgiving game at Detroit. PSA has given a 10 to 1,005 of the 5,505 copies it has graded, a lower gem rate than Burrow's or Allen's rookie. I'd buy before the holiday rather than after a big game on national TV.

6. Jerry Rice, 1986 Topps, PSA 8

​

A PSA 8 sells for about $427, with 33 sold in the last 30 days. I'd buy the 8 under $430 because it's the grade of Rice's rookie you can sell in any week.

7. Jayden Daniels, 2024 Prizm Silver, PSA 10

​

A PSA 10 Silver sells for about $608. In October I said to wait for $600. The Silver got there in November. PSA has given a 10 to 810 of the 6,791 Silvers it has graded. I'd buy one at $600 now.

8. Walter Payton, 1976 Topps, PSA 6

​

A PSA 6 sells for about $636. Payton was on October's list at $625 and has held his price since. A 6 comes up for sale about every other day, with 15 sales in the last 30 days. I'd keep buying the 6 around $630.

Which high-end football cards are worth buying?

9. Josh Allen, 2018 Prizm, PSA 10

​

A PSA 10 sells for about $750. Allen has the Bills at 8-1 and sits at +350 for MVP, second behind Burrow. The Bills host the Chiefs on Thanksgiving night. That puts the two high-end picks on this list on the same field. I'd buy at $750 or less instead of chasing it after a big night.

10. Patrick Mahomes, 2017 Donruss Optic, PSA 10

​

A PSA 10 sells for about $1,436. Mahomes tied Tom Brady as the fastest to 100 regular-season wins in October and threw five touchdown passes at Atlanta on Nov. 15. His card didn't move with either. His first Topps autographs arrive in 2026 Topps Chrome Football this week. I'd buy the Optic at about $1,436 before the Chiefs play at Buffalo on Thanksgiving night.

How did October's football picks do?

Of October's ten picks, five held their price, two went up, and two went down. Daniels landed on the price I told you to wait for:

  • Fernando Mendoza, Rainbow Foil, raw: under $10 then, about $12 now
  • Johnny Unitas, 1957 Topps, PSA 4: $585 then, $826 on its last sale, Oct. 27
  • Jayden Daniels, Prizm Silver, PSA 10: wait for $600 then, about $608 now
  • Walter Payton, 1976 Topps, PSA 6: $625 then, about $636 now
  • Josh Allen, 2018 Prizm, PSA 10: $750 or less then, about $750 now
  • Patrick Mahomes, Donruss Optic, PSA 10: $1,450 or less then, about $1,436 now
  • Puka Nacua, 2023 Prizm, PSA 10: a $55 bid then, about $53 now
  • Jim Brown, 1958 Topps, PSA 4: $1,100 to $1,750 then, $1,626 and $1,525 in its two November sales
  • Drake Maye, 2024 Prizm, PSA 10: under $140 then, about $130 now
  • Tom Brady, 2000 Bowman Chrome, PSA 7: $5,000 then, $3,450 to $4,900 over the last 30 days

NBC Sports reported that Maye is believed to have fractured his ankle in Munich on Nov. 15 and is likely out for the season. He's off this month's list. So are Nacua, Brady, Unitas, and Jim Brown.

We'll update this list every month.

  1. Prices are completed sales on eBay, Fanatics Collect, Goldin, Alt and Heritage, checked on Oct. 17, 2026, against the recent sales recorded for each card at the same grade. Auction-house prices include the buyer's premium. The table compares the middle sale at each card's grade from Sept. 27 to Oct. 10 with Oct. 11 to 17. Prediction-market odds are from Polymarket and Kalshi, read at 1:10 p.m. Pacific on Oct. 17, as the midpoint of the bid and ask. PSA population counts are from GemRate, updated Oct. 16.

Football cards

View all

Cookie preferences

Choose whether CardWire may use optional analytics. You can change this choice at any time.

Security and your privacy choice. Always on.

Helps CardWire understand which public features readers use.

Analytics is disabled for this browser or environment.