Search All 6,451 Items on PSA's Stolen List Before You Buy a Slab
Thieves took 6,451 items from a FedEx truck carrying PSA customer orders on Oct. 13. Our search covers every cert on PSA's list and prices 1,922 of its 3,916 different cards by grade.
How to check a PSA cert against the stolen list
Paste a PSA cert number into the search above to check it against the list PSA published on Oct. 23. A match comes back with a black Stolen banner and the card's price range at each grade. You can also type a player, a Pokémon or a set to see every copy on the list, sorted by value or by how many copies were taken.
Then run the same number through PSA's cert verification. PSA has deactivated the cert of every stolen graded item. If a cert doesn't come up there, don't buy the slab.
What's on PSA's stolen list
Thieves broke into the FedEx truck that picked up customer orders outside PSA's Santa Ana, California, facility on Oct. 13. Santa Ana police put the loss at $963,000. PSA's list names all 6,451 items by cert number, but it never says what grade any of them got.
The biggest name on it is a 1999 Pokémon Base Set Charizard holo, 1st Edition, cert 177980867. A PSA 7 of that card has sold for $18,910 to $32,600 since July 25. A PSA 10 sold for $1,380,000 at Fanatics Collect on Oct. 23. PSA's list doesn't say which one was on the truck.
Most of the haul is new, with 4,669 of the 6,451 items made in 2020 or later. Pokémon makes up 2,978 of the items and One Piece another 898. There are more Victor Wembanyama cards on it (202) than Michael Jordan cards (185).
After the Charizard, I'd watch for the vintage Pokémon. The list has four 2002 Legendary Collection Charizard reverse foils. PSA 10s of that card went for around $122,000 in June. This month, four PSA 10s of it sold for $468,000 to $660,000 at Fanatics Collect. The list also has two 2005 Gold Star Rayquazas. A PSA 10 of that one sold for $682,500 at Alt on July 9.
We priced 1,922 of the 3,916 different cards on the list by grade, from sales where we found them and from estimates where we didn't.
What to do if a cert is on the list
Don't buy the slab. Call the FBI's Los Angeles office at 310-477-6565 instead and ask for the duty agent on the PSA theft. PSA shared the list with marketplace sellers, auction houses, and digital commerce platforms that are watching for the cards.
What PSA owes collectors who lost cards
PSA has refunded the grading fees on every affected order. Customers who shipped on PSA's return label get fair market value up to each item's declared insured value. PSA says those payments are already going out. If a card turns up later, its owner can keep the money or take the card back. Our explainer breaks down who is legally responsible when PSA loses your cards.